Derek Jeter House: Inside the Yankee Legend’s Iconic Mansions

It started with a photo of a castle rising above Greenwood Lake—and that single image led me deep into the real estate world of Derek Jeter. Known for his 20 legendary seasons with the New York Yankees, Jeter built a reputation on discipline, privacy, and excellence—and his homes follow the same pattern.

From that fortress-like lakefront estate to his massive waterfront manor in Tampa Bay—famously rented by Tom Brady—every property reflects elite taste and quiet power. Much like the architectural grandeur seen in the Alex Ovechkin House, these are not just luxury homes. They are carefully chosen spaces that mirror a career built on consistency, control, and legacy.

Derek Jeter House – Property Snapshot

This comprehensive overview captures the vital statistics and legacy of the most famous residence in Tampa Bay history.

Derek Jeter House Location

Located at 58 Bahama Circle, this premier Davis Islands estate offers elite waterfront privacy behind a towering stone wall. Just minutes from downtown Tampa and Amalie Arena, the exclusive neighborhood features tree-lined streets and a private airport. Long a sanctuary for professional athletes and celebrities, the community provides direct bay access while remaining a quiet, secure Mediterranean-inspired island retreat.

My Visit to Derek Jeter Davis Islands Mansion

AsTodd Lynch from Urbansfreaks, I have to be honest — getting access to even the exterior of this home took real planning. A local agent guided me around the perimeter, sharing insights from when the property was listed for $29 million. We drove across the Davis Islands Bridge just before sunset, and the shift was immediate — quieter streets, calmer energy, a sense of privacy.

Turning onto Bahama Circle, a long stone privacy wall revealed itself, stretching across the entire lot. Behind it, glimpses of rooftops and swaying palms built anticipation. Standing at the gated entrance, the carved limestone facade came into view, and the scale was undeniable. This wasn’t a house trying to impress — it simply did. My guide described the 24-foot foyer inside as breathtaking, a rare reaction even in luxury real estate — and I had no reason to doubt it. 🏡

Derek Jeter House Tour: Interior and others features

Step inside the legendary “St. Jetersburg,” a 22,000-square-foot masterpiece featuring a soaring 24-foot foyer and floor-to-ceiling glass walls. This elite estate boasts a professional-grade gym, a private movie theater, and a massive clubroom complete with a full-service bar and billiards.

Derek Jeter House Enterance

Step through the front door and the first thing that hits you is height. The foyer soars 24 feet — a full two-story atrium of space with floor-to-ceiling glass panels framing the entry. Hand-polished Venetian plaster covers the walls. Mosaic tile floors lead you forward. Solid hardwood takes over as you move deeper into the home. Natural light pours in from multiple directions. It is dramatic without being overdone.

Derek Jeter House Living Room

The main living room is generous and open, flowing toward the bay-facing windows that frame unobstructed water views. The furniture layout is designed for comfort and conversation. A fireplace anchors one wall. Silk draperies frame the windows. The color palette is rich but calm — deep neutrals and warm woods. The space connects easily to the outdoor terraces, making indoor-outdoor living feel seamless.

Derek Jeter House Kitchen

The kitchen is built to professional standards. Custom cabinetry lines the walls, paired with high-end countertops and professional-grade appliances. The layout is efficient — designed for both daily family use and large-scale entertaining. A scullery and additional laundry room sit adjacent, keeping the main kitchen clutter-free. A full home automation system controls lighting, temperature, and appliances throughout.

Derek Jeter House Master Bedroom

The master suite is 2,500 square feet on its own — roughly the size of a generous family home. Two custom walk-in closets are each the size of most normal bedrooms. A fireplace, sitting area, and private balcony with direct bay views complete the retreat feel. The bedroom itself is designed for absolute comfort — a calm, luxurious space where the outside world simply does not intrude.

Derek Jeter House Bathroom

The master bathroom is spa-level in every detail. A steam shower, soaking tub, dual vanities, and premium stone finishes throughout. The materials — marble, polished stone, custom tile — are among the finest available. Lighting is layered to create a warm, relaxing ambiance. In total, the home has 16 bathrooms — 8 full and 8 half — ensuring that no guest ever waits.

Derek Jeter House Home Office

Beyond the main living areas, the home includes a professional gym, a wine cellar, an in-home movie theater, an in-law suite, and an au-pair wing complete with its own living area and kitchen. Every function has a dedicated, well-designed space. This is a home built for a full, active lifestyle — not just a showpiece.

Derek Jeter House Outdoor Living Spaces

The Jeter estate’s outdoor spaces are extraordinary, featuring an 80-foot saltwater lap pool and 345 feet of breathtaking bay frontage. With 9,000 square feet of terraces, a private dock with two boat lifts, and a professional-grade outdoor kitchen, the property offers world-class luxury. This peaceful sanctuary provides an elite waterfront experience defined by privacy and expansive, open-sky views.

Property History

Derek Jeter’s iconic Davis Islands estate, famously nicknamed “St. Jetersburg,” was completed in 2011 and later rented by Tom Brady. After selling for a record $22.5 million in 2023, the landmark was demolished in 2024. Much like the custom-built Simone Biles House in Texas, which features personalized athlete-centric amenities, the new owner is replacing the structure with a 30,000-square-foot modern mansion. Prior to demolition, Jeter’s original high-end fixtures and appliances were donated to Habitat for Humanity to support local community housing.

Additional Properties – Derek Jeter’s Real Estate Portfolio

Explore the Hall of Famer’s impressive multi-state property holdings, ranging from a historic lakeside “castle” in New York to ultra-luxurious waterfront estates in South Florida. This diverse portfolio showcases the Yankee legend’s transition from Manhattan’s elite penthouses to expansive family compounds in the Sunshine State.

Greenwood Lake Estate – New York / New Jersey

Location: Greenwood Lake, NY (just north of NJ state line). Built: 1903 (originally). Main House: 12,000 sq ft on 4 acres. Total Compound: 50,000+ sq ft. Bedrooms: 6. Bathrooms: 13. Kitchens: 4. Listed: $14.75M (2018). Sold: $5.1M (2024). Features: Stone turret, infinity pool, lagoon, 700 ft lakefront, waterfalls, replica Statue of Liberty, elevator, 2 conference rooms, guest house, pool house, boat house.

Avila Golf & Country Club – North Tampa

Location: Avila Golf & Country Club, North Tampa, Florida. Size: 4,493 sq ft. Estimated Value: ~$1 million. A secondary Tampa residence inside one of Florida’s most exclusive and guarded gated communities. Avila is a private golf and country club community with 24-hour security and a strictly members-only feel.

How Much Is Derek Jeter House Worth?

Jeter built the Davis Islands home for an estimated $7.7 million during construction. He listed it in 2020 for $29 million and sold it in 2023 for $22.5 million — a Tampa Bay record and still one of the highest residential sales in Florida history. The Greenwood Lake, NY estate was originally listed at $14.75 million in 2018, reduced to $12.75 million in 2021, and eventually sold in 2024 for $5.1 million after a failed auction. His Trump World Tower penthouse in Manhattan was purchased for $12.6 million in 2001 and sold in 2012 for $15.5 million.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Find quick answers to the most common inquiries regarding the history, sale, and future of Derek Jeter’s legendary Tampa estate. This section covers everything from the record-breaking sales figures to the current redevelopment plans for the Davis Islands property.

What is Derek Jeter House?

Derek Jeter’s most famous home is his custom English manor estate at 58 Bahama Circle, Davis Islands, Tampa, Florida. Built between 2005 and 2011, it spans approximately 22,000 square feet with 7 bedrooms, 16 bathrooms, an 80-foot saltwater pool, and 345 feet of open bay frontage. It sold for a Tampa Bay record of $22.5 million in 2023.

Where is Derek Jeter House in Tampa?

Derek Jeter’s Tampa house is located at 58 Bahama Circle on Davis Islands — a prestigious waterfront island community just south of downtown Tampa. It sits on the western bay shore of Davis Islands with direct open-water views across Tampa Bay.

Where is Derek Jeter House in Miami?

After selling his Tampa estate, Derek Jeter relocated to Miami, Florida. He lives in the Coral Gables area of Miami, where he served as CEO and co-owner of the Miami Marlins. Coral Gables is one of Miami’s most exclusive and upscale residential neighborhoods.

Where is Derek Jeter House on Davis Island?

The Derek Jeter house on Davis Islands is at 58 Bahama Circle, on the western bay-facing shore of Davis Islands, Tampa, FL 33606. It is the largest assembled waterfront property ever built on Davis Islands, sitting on 1.25 acres with 345 feet of open bay.

Where is Derek Jeter House in Greenwood Lake?

Derek Jeter’s Greenwood Lake estate sits just north of the New Jersey state line on Greenwood Lake, New York. The historic compound includes a 12,000 sq ft main house on 4 acres with 700 feet of lakefront. It was originally built in 1903 and sold in 2024 for $5.1 million.

Where is Derek Jeter House in New York?

In New York City, Derek Jeter owned a 5,425 sq ft penthouse at Trump World Tower, 845 United Nations Plaza in Midtown Manhattan. He bought it in 2001 for $12.6 million and sold it in 2012 for $15.5 million.

Where is Derek Jeter House in Tampa FL?

Derek Jeter’s Tampa FL house is located at 58 Bahama Circle, Davis Islands, Tampa, FL 33606. Davis Islands is accessible via the Davis Islands Bridge from Bayshore Boulevard in South Tampa.

Where is Derek Jeter House in Florida?

Derek Jeter has owned multiple Florida properties. His most famous is the Davis Islands Tampa mansion. He also maintained a smaller home in Avila Golf & Country Club in North Tampa. He currently resides in the Miami / Coral Gables area of Florida.

Where is Derek Jeter House in Coral Gables?

Derek Jeter’s Coral Gables residence is in the upscale Coral Gables neighborhood of Miami, Florida. Coral Gables is known for its Mediterranean Revival architecture, waterfront estates, and proximity to downtown Miami and Brickell. Exact address details are kept private.

Is Derek Jeter House for Sale?

The original Derek Jeter Davis Islands Tampa mansion is no longer for sale — it was sold in 2023 for $22.5 million and subsequently demolished. A new 30,000 sq ft estate is being built on the same lot by Ellison Construction. The Greenwood Lake NY estate was sold in 2024 for $5.1 million and is no longer on the market.

Where Does Derek Jeter Live Now?

Derek Jeter currently lives in Miami, Florida, with his wife Hannah Davis Jeter and their four daughters — Bella, Story, River, and Kaius. After selling his iconic Davis Islands Tampa mansion for $22.5 million in 2023, Jeter settled permanently in the Coral Gables area of Miami — one of the most exclusive and private residential neighborhoods in South Florida. The move made sense given his role as CEO and part-owner of the Miami Marlins. He also frequently appears on Fox Sports as part of their MLB broadcasting team, making Miami the perfect home base for both his business and media career.

Final Thoughts

The homes of Derek Jeter tell you exactly who he is. From Greenwood Lake to Tampa and beyond, every property reflects the same values — excellence, privacy, and uncompromising quality. These aren’t just houses. They’re legacies built in stone, glass, and water. ✨

What makes them stand out, from a design perspective, is the consistency. Grand architecture paired with modern livability. English manor elegance, waterfront openness, and interiors that feel both powerful and personal. It’s bold, but never careless. Refined, but never distant.And that’s exactly what people are searching for today. Not just scale — but presence. Homes that feel intentional, commanding, and designed to last for generations.

If this kind of home speaks to you, don’t ignore it — there is a reason it resonates. Home Tours like these are not just impressive, they define what true legacy living looks like. 🏡✨